The Importance of Humanizing Heroes and Villains

By Scott T. Allison

Human beings have a remarkable talent for turning other people into something larger—or smaller—than human. When someone performs an extraordinary act of courage or compassion, we may elevate them into a saint, smoothing away flaws and imagining a purity no real person possesses. And when someone commits terrible acts, we may transform them into a monster, a creature fundamentally unlike us. Both impulses are understandable. Both distort reality.

My colleague Mohsen Askari calls the corrective to hero worship hero fallibilization, which he defines as the recognition that admirable people are imperfect. Oskar Schindler saved more than a thousand Jews during the Holocaust, an achievement worthy of deep respect. Yet Schindler was also complicated and flawed. Acknowledging those imperfections doesn’t debunk his heroism; it simply allows us to admire without idealizing and critique without cancelling.

If heroes benefit from fallibilization, villains have a parallel process: villain humanization. The phrase can sound unsettling. Why humanize people responsible for horrific acts? Because humanization is not exoneration.

Consider Adolf Hitler. We can acknowledge that he loved classical music, showed affection toward people in his inner circle, and displayed other recognizably human qualities. None of these facts remotely counterbalances the millions of deaths and immeasurable suffering for which he bears responsibility. Seeing someone’s human traits doesn’t lessen the weight of their wrongdoing. To humanize Hitler is not to soften our judgment. It is to confront the far more disturbing truth that he was human.

Calling perpetrators of extraordinary evil “monsters” can paradoxically make evil easier to live with. Monsters belong to another category. If evil is committed only by creatures unlike us, then ordinary people need not look too closely at themselves. The famed psychologist Philip Zimbardo spent much of his career challenging this comforting assumption, showing how situations, institutions, and group pressures can lead ordinary people toward actions they once considered unimaginable. Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn captured the same truth when he wrote that the line between good and evil runs through every human heart.

The dynamic works in the opposite direction as well. When we turn heroes into gods, extraordinary goodness becomes something only extraordinary beings can achieve. Askari argues that hero worship can shrink our own sense of agency. We admire from below rather than asking what parts of the hero’s behavior might be available to us. Fallibilizing heroes changes the message: an imperfect person like me may be capable of extraordinary good. That realization is aspirational.

Humanizing villains delivers the complementary warning: a recognizably human person like me may be capable of participating in harm. That realization is humbling—and protective.

Together, these insights reveal four ways we construct morally significant people. At one extreme is hero worship, where admirable individuals become godlike. Moving toward complexity brings hero fallibilization, where heroes remain inspiring but recognizably imperfect. On the darker side lies villain humanization, where we condemn terrible behavior while acknowledging the humanity of the wrongdoer. At the far extreme is villain demonization, where the perpetrator becomes a monster. The endpoints—god and monster—are psychologically seductive because they compress complicated people into simple moral essences. The middle positions ask more of us.

Carl Jung’s theory of archetypes offers another lens. Humans naturally organize experience through powerful images of heroes, shadows, saviors, and demons. These archetypes can illuminate reality, but they can also overwhelm it. Mature perception requires remembering that the archetype is not the person.

This is why humanizing both heroes and villains matters. Hero worship and villain demonization allow us to locate extraordinary good and extraordinary evil somewhere outside ourselves. Fallibilization and humanization return them to the human family. Fallibilizing heroes makes goodness less remote. Humanizing villains makes evil less alien.

One realization should give us hope. The other should make us vigilant. Together they remind us of an uncomfortable but empowering truth: the capacities for extraordinary good and extraordinary evil do not belong to different species of people. They belong to us.

= = = = = = = = = = =

About Scott Allison

Scott Allison has authored numerous books, including 'Heroes' and 'Heroic Leadership'. He is Professor Emeritus of Psychology at the University of Richmond where he has published extensively on heroism and leadership. His other books include The Romance of Heroism, the Handbook of Heroism, Everyday Heroism, and the Hazards of Great Leadership. His work has appeared in USA Today, National Public Radio, the New York Times, the Los Angeles Times, Slate Magazine, MSNBC, CBS, Psychology Today, and the Christian Science Monitor. He has received Richmond's Distinguished Educator Award and the Virginia Council of Higher Education's Outstanding Faculty Award.