Category Archives: Commentary and Analysis

The Importance of Humanizing Heroes and Villains

By Scott T. Allison

Human beings have a remarkable talent for turning other people into something larger—or smaller—than human. When someone performs an extraordinary act of courage or compassion, we may elevate them into a saint, smoothing away flaws and imagining a purity no real person possesses. And when someone commits terrible acts, we may transform them into a monster, a creature fundamentally unlike us. Both impulses are understandable. Both distort reality.

My colleague Mohsen Askari calls the corrective to hero worship hero fallibilization, which he defines as the recognition that admirable people are imperfect. Oskar Schindler saved more than a thousand Jews during the Holocaust, an achievement worthy of deep respect. Yet Schindler was also complicated and flawed. Acknowledging those imperfections doesn’t debunk his heroism; it simply allows us to admire without idealizing and critique without cancelling.

If heroes benefit from fallibilization, villains have a parallel process: villain humanization. The phrase can sound unsettling. Why humanize people responsible for horrific acts? Because humanization is not exoneration.

Consider Adolf Hitler. We can acknowledge that he loved classical music, showed affection toward people in his inner circle, and displayed other recognizably human qualities. None of these facts remotely counterbalances the millions of deaths and immeasurable suffering for which he bears responsibility. Seeing someone’s human traits doesn’t lessen the weight of their wrongdoing. To humanize Hitler is not to soften our judgment. It is to confront the far more disturbing truth that he was human.

Calling perpetrators of extraordinary evil “monsters” can paradoxically make evil easier to live with. Monsters belong to another category. If evil is committed only by creatures unlike us, then ordinary people need not look too closely at themselves. The famed psychologist Philip Zimbardo spent much of his career challenging this comforting assumption, showing how situations, institutions, and group pressures can lead ordinary people toward actions they once considered unimaginable. Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn captured the same truth when he wrote that the line between good and evil runs through every human heart.

The dynamic works in the opposite direction as well. When we turn heroes into gods, extraordinary goodness becomes something only extraordinary beings can achieve. Askari argues that hero worship can shrink our own sense of agency. We admire from below rather than asking what parts of the hero’s behavior might be available to us. Fallibilizing heroes changes the message: an imperfect person like me may be capable of extraordinary good. That realization is aspirational.

Humanizing villains delivers the complementary warning: a recognizably human person like me may be capable of participating in harm. That realization is humbling—and protective.

Together, these insights reveal four ways we construct morally significant people. At one extreme is hero worship, where admirable individuals become godlike. Moving toward complexity brings hero fallibilization, where heroes remain inspiring but recognizably imperfect. On the darker side lies villain humanization, where we condemn terrible behavior while acknowledging the humanity of the wrongdoer. At the far extreme is villain demonization, where the perpetrator becomes a monster. The endpoints—god and monster—are psychologically seductive because they compress complicated people into simple moral essences. The middle positions ask more of us.

Carl Jung’s theory of archetypes offers another lens. Humans naturally organize experience through powerful images of heroes, shadows, saviors, and demons. These archetypes can illuminate reality, but they can also overwhelm it. Mature perception requires remembering that the archetype is not the person.

This is why humanizing both heroes and villains matters. Hero worship and villain demonization allow us to locate extraordinary good and extraordinary evil somewhere outside ourselves. Fallibilization and humanization return them to the human family. Fallibilizing heroes makes goodness less remote. Humanizing villains makes evil less alien.

One realization should give us hope. The other should make us vigilant. Together they remind us of an uncomfortable but empowering truth: the capacities for extraordinary good and extraordinary evil do not belong to different species of people. They belong to us.

= = = = = = = = = = =

When Ordinary People Become Heroes

What Sri Lanka’s civilian-bravery stories can teach us about courage, compassion, and human behaviour

By Philip Chandraratne

A young girl falls from the third floor of a school building. There is almost no time to think. Fifteen-year-old J. A. Malkanthi Dhammika Jayasuriya, a Grade 11 student and head prefect at Sunethra Devi Girls’ School in Pepiliyana, sees the child falling. She positions herself underneath the girl and catches her. The impact knocks Dhammika down. Remarkably, neither child is injured.

For this act, Dhammika received the 1999 Gold Medal of Civilian Bravery from the Foundation for Civilian Bravery.

What happened in those few seconds? Did she calculate the danger? Did she consciously decide to become a hero? Or did something faster and deeper take over—the impulse to protect another human being?

We don’t know. And that is precisely why such stories deserve more than admiration. They deserve study.

Another Person, Another Emergency

Years later, another Sri Lankan faced a very different situation. On 19 November 2016, Dhanushka Lakmal Kumara, a driver, was returning home when he noticed people gathered on a bridge over the Gin Ganga at Baddegama. Looking into the river, he realised that two women were drowning.

Other people were present, but nobody was volunteering to enter the water. Dhanushka went down to the river and rescued the first woman. He then returned to search for the second. Swimming against the current, he eventually brought her to safety with the assistance of a rope thrown by a police officer.

The women were strangers. They were not his relatives or friends. Yet, faced with another person’s imminent death, he moved towards the danger. Why?

The Mystery of Civilian Bravery

We often use words such as courage, heroism, altruism and compassion as though we already understand them. But describing behaviour is not the same as explaining it. A person who voluntarily risks their own life to save another presents one of the clearest examples of high-stakes helping behaviour.

The Foundation for Civilian Bravery has used a practical definition of civilian bravery centred on the voluntary saving of a life in peril at the risk of one’s own life. The distinction is important. A soldier may be required by professional duty to enter danger. A firefighter may be trained and expected to rescue people from a burning building.

But a civilian who suddenly encounters someone in mortal danger has no such professional obligation. The person faces a choice: Do I act—or do I remain an observer? 

Sri Lanka Has Been Recording These Moments for Decades

Since 1993, the Foundation for Civilian Bravery has identified and recognised exceptional acts of civilian bravery in Sri Lanka. Its published record, Civilian Bravery in Sri Lanka 1993–2018, documents 84 recognised cases—22 Gold and 62 Silver—over a 25-year period.

The incidents are diverse. People have entered rivers, wells and other dangerous waters. They have responded to road and railway accidents, fires, disasters and other situations in which another person’s life was in immediate danger.

One example occurred in 2016, when W. H. G. Wikramathilaka saw an agricultural research officer swept into a flooded lake at Yakkalamulla. He entered the dangerous water and succeeded in saving her life while exposing himself to considerable risk.

These are not simply stories about medals. They are documented examples of human behaviour under extraordinary circumstances. Collectively, they raise questions that deserve scientific investigation.

Why Does One Person Act While Others Watch?

Perhaps the most intriguing feature of some incidents is the presence of bystanders. In the Baddegama river incident, Dhanushka saw that two women were drowning while other people were gathered nearby. He entered the river when nobody else volunteered.

This raises an important psychological question: when an emergency occurs in a public place, what determines whether an individual becomes an active rescuer or remains an observer?

Is it personality? Empathy? Previous experience? Confidence? Risk perception? Moral responsibility? Physical ability? Or does the situation itself create a moment in which action becomes almost automatic?

Perhaps the answer is not one factor alone. Perhaps bravery emerges from an interaction between the individual, the situation and the social environment.

The Stranger Question

Why do people sometimes risk their lives for strangers? Family relationships provide an obvious context for helping behaviour. We naturally expect parents to protect their children and family members to help one another.

But when the person in danger is unknown to the rescuer, the explanation becomes more challenging. The Sri Lankan cases include people who intervened to save individuals with whom they had no apparent personal relationship. That makes civilian bravery particularly interesting for research into human helping and altruism.

The question is not simply: Why are some people brave? It is: Why would a person accept a potentially fatal cost to save another human being with whom there is no previous relationship?

Heroism Doesn’t Begin with the Medal

A heroic act does not exist only at the moment when the rescue takes place. First there is the emergency. Then there is the decision to intervene. Then comes the outcome. Afterwards, witnesses remember what happened. Someone reports the incident. An organisation investigates it. Finally, society decides whether the action deserves recognition.

The Foundation’s long-running record therefore represents more than a collection of heroic stories. It also provides a record of how a society identifies, documents and remembers exceptional acts of citizenship.

This creates an unusual opportunity. The archive may potentially become a starting point for systematic research.

From Stories to Science

Imagine transforming these historical accounts into a research database. Researchers could ask the following questions:

  • Who was the rescuer?
  • How old was the person?
  • Was the victim a stranger, friend or relative?
  • What type of emergency occurred?
  • How great was the apparent danger?
  • Were other people present?
  • Did the rescuer have previous relevant experience?
  • Was there time to deliberate, or was the response immediate?
  • What happened to the rescuer and victim afterwards?
  • How was the act subsequently recognised?

Such questions could transform an archive of individual stories into a resource for studying exceptional human behaviour. But an important qualification is necessary. The Foundation’s archive is an archive of recognised cases, not a representative sample of all emergencies or all people. It cannot, by itself, tell us how common civilian bravery is in the general population. Nor can it establish why people behave heroically.

What it can provide is something valuable at the beginning of a research programme: real-world cases from which scientifically testable questions can be developed.

Recognition Matters, Too

Why do we recognise civilian bravery? In his contribution to Civilian Bravery in Sri Lanka 1993–2018, the late Judge C. G. Weeramantry emphasised the broader social value of recognising exceptional self-sacrifice. Recognition can expose younger generations to admirable conduct and communicate society’s appreciation of exemplary behaviour.

When a society tells a young person, “This is behaviour worth admiring,” it is also communicating something about the kind of society it values. A medal can therefore be more than a reward. It can be a social signal.

And that raises another research question: Can recognition itself influence future behaviour?

What Does Heroism Tell Us About Ourselves?

Every emergency can create a tension between self-preservation and concern for another person. Most of the time, self-preservation is entirely natural. Yet occasionally, someone crosses that boundary.

A schoolgirl sees a child falling and moves underneath her. A driver sees two strangers drowning and enters a dangerous river. A passer-by sees someone in peril and decides that he cannot simply watch.

These moments are brief. But they reveal something profound about human beings. They suggest that alongside our powerful instinct for self-preservation, human beings also possess the capacity—under certain circumstances—to place another person’s survival above their own immediate safety.

We still know much less about this capacity than we might wish.

From Celebrating Heroes to Understanding Heroism

For more than three decades, the Foundation for Civilian Bravery has had a simple purpose: to ensure that acts of civilian courage are not forgotten. But perhaps the time has come to ask a further question: Can these stories help us understand heroism scientifically?

Sri Lanka offers an unusual starting point. There is a documented historical archive accumulated through a long-running recognition system, containing real-world examples of people confronting extraordinary situations.

The archive does not provide all the answers. It provides an opportunity to ask better questions. Why did Dhammika act? Why did Dhanushka act when others remained on the bridge? Why do some people move towards danger? Why do some help strangers? What happens psychologically before, during and after the act? How do ordinary acts of bravery become recognised as heroic? And can societies cultivate conditions in which courageous helping behaviour becomes more likely?

Perhaps the ultimate purpose of studying civilian bravery is therefore not simply to understand heroes. It is to understand human potential.

Because somewhere, at some unexpected moment, an ordinary person may face an extraordinary choice. And what that person chooses to do may determine whether another human being lives or dies. That is the moment when an ordinary person becomes a hero.

And perhaps it is also the moment when science should begin asking why.

= = = = = = = = =

Philip Chandraratne is a Sri Lankan visionary best known as the pioneer and founder of the Foundation of Civilian Bravery. He established the organization to formally recognize and celebrate ordinary citizens who risk their lives to perform extraordinary acts of bravery outside the scope of their standard professional duties.

Leadership Illiteracy: Why We Keep Choosing the Wrong Leaders

By Scott T. Allison

What makes someone a great leader?

Most of us think we know. We look for confidence. Presence. Strength. Charisma. We’re drawn to people who command attention—those who seem certain, bold, and larger than life.

But what if we’re using the wrong criteria altogether?

A growing problem in modern society is what we might call leadership illiteracy: the tendency to evaluate leaders using the wrong signals. Instead of focusing on what truly matters, we rely on surface-level cues—style over substance, appearance over character. And the consequences can be profound.

The Illusion of Leadership

Leadership illiteracy begins with a simple mistake: confusing how a leader looks with who a leader is. We instinctively equate charisma with competence, confidence with credibility, and strength with moral authority. These assumptions feel natural—but they are often wrong.

Psychologically, this reflects a well-known bias: we rely on quick, visible cues to make judgments about others. In leadership contexts, however, this shortcut becomes especially dangerous. It leads to what we might call the heroism attribution error—the tendency to assume that someone who looks like a hero actually is one.

In reality, many of the traits we admire most in leaders are morally neutral. Charisma, boldness, and determination can serve noble purposes—or destructive ones. Leadership illiteracy occurs when we fail to tell the difference.

The Container vs. the Content

One way to understand this problem is to distinguish between the container of leadership and its content. The container is what we see first: charisma, confidence, resilience, communication skill. These qualities are vivid, engaging, and easy to recognize.

The content is what truly defines leadership: values, moral commitments, and how a leader treats others—especially those with less power. The problem is that the container is loud, while the content is quiet.

We are naturally drawn to leaders who appear strong and inspiring. But these traits tell us very little about whether someone is ethical, compassionate, or trustworthy. In fact, many qualities we associate with heroes—being bold, inspiring, or determined—can just as easily describe villains. These traits are tools. Their moral value depends entirely on how they are used.

Leadership illiteracy is, at its core, a failure to distinguish between container and content.

Why We Keep Getting It Wrong

If the distinction seems obvious, why do we keep making the same mistake? Because human attention is not neutral. We are wired to notice what stands out. Psychologists call this salience—the tendency for vivid, attention-grabbing features to dominate our perception. Charismatic leaders benefit enormously from this bias.

They capture our attention quickly. And once they do, we begin to fill in the blanks. We assume competence. We assume integrity. We assume leadership.

But these assumptions are often unwarranted. This helps explain why people sometimes elevate leaders who are confident but not compassionate, persuasive but not ethical. Charisma creates an illusion of depth where little exists. And once we are impressed, it becomes harder to step back and evaluate critically.

The Real Cost of Leadership Illiteracy

Leadership illiteracy is not just a cognitive error—it has real-world consequences. When individuals and societies prioritize style over substance, they risk empowering leaders whose moral compass is weak or self-serving. History offers many examples of leaders who were compelling and persuasive, yet deeply harmful.

The issue is not that charisma is bad. Charisma can be a force for good. The problem is that charisma is not a reliable indicator of moral character. When we evaluate leaders based on the wrong criteria, we increase the likelihood of poor—and sometimes disastrous—choices.

What We Should Be Looking For

If we are illiterate in leadership, the solution is not to abandon judgment—it is to learn to read leadership differently. Across research on heroism and moral behavior, one theme appears consistently: true leadership is rooted in concern for others. The traits that distinguish genuine leaders are not about dominance or visibility. Instead, they include:

  • selflessness
  • moral integrity
  • compassion
  • a commitment to helping and protecting others

These qualities reflect the moral content of leadership. Importantly, they are often less visible than charisma. They do not always capture attention. But they are far more predictive of whether a leader’s actions will benefit or harm others.

Mythologist Joseph Campbell described the hero’s journey as a transformation from self-centeredness to service. At its end, the hero recognizes their deep connection to others. This idea echoes across traditions. Martin Luther King Jr. emphasized our “interrelated structure of reality,” while Albert Einstein urged us to expand our circle of compassion beyond ourselves.

These perspectives converge on a simple insight: The best leaders unite. They do not divide.

Leadership as Love in Action

At its core, effective leadership can be understood in one phrase: Love in action. This is not about sentimentality. It is about behavior—how leaders act in relation to others. When people take risks to protect others, stand up against injustice, or act with integrity in difficult situations, they are expressing leadership grounded in care.

This kind of leadership appears in everyday life:

  • a teacher supporting a struggling student
  • a colleague speaking up against unfairness
  • a community member helping others in crisis
  • an individual choosing integrity over convenience

These actions may not be flashy. But they reveal something more important than charisma: character.

Becoming More Literate About Leadership

If leadership illiteracy is the problem, then the solution is learning to ask better questions. Instead of asking: “Is this person impressive?” We should ask: “Who does this person serve?”

Do their actions benefit others, or primarily themselves? Do they expand compassion, or create division? Do they take responsibility, or deflect blame?

These questions shift our focus from appearance to substance. They help us evaluate the content of leadership, not just its container.

Final Thought

We all want strong leaders—people who inspire us and guide us through uncertainty.  But if we rely on the wrong signals, we will continue to choose poorly.

Leadership illiteracy is not inevitable. It is a skill gap—one we can correct. Because in the end, leadership is not about who stands out. It is about who shows up for others—consistently, compassionately, and with integrity.

And that is something no amount of charisma can replace.

References

Allison, S. T. (2024). Heroism attribution error. In S. T. Allison, J. K. Beggan, and G. R. Goethals (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Heroism Studies. Springer.

Allison, S. T. (2025). The love with a thousand faces: Heroism as embodied love in action. Heroism Science, 9, 1-30.

Allison, S. T., & Goethals, G. R. (2024). Heroic leadership: An influence taxonomy of 100 exceptional individuals (2nd ed.). Routledge.

Goethals, G. R., Allison, S. T., & Sorenson, G. J. (Eds.) (2023). The SAGE encyclopedia of leadership studies. Sage.

Major Contributions to Heroism Studies by Scott T. Allison’s Research Lab: 2005-Present

Since 2005, Scott Allison’s Heroism Studies Lab has identified many principles, phenomena, and theories of heroism. These contributions illuminate:

  • how people perceive heroes
  • how heroes influence individuals and societies
  • how heroism itself develops

The contributions below are presented in reverse chronological order so that returning visitors can immediately see the newest developments. Together they trace the continuing evolution of heroism science, from early discoveries about hero perception to recent work on the developmental systems theory of heroism.

  • Reciprocal Developmental Systems Theory of Heroism (2027)

This theory recognizes that heroes are not born fully formed, nor do societies evolve just by accident. Both develop through an ongoing process of reciprocal influence. Heroes are shaped by families, mentors, adversity, communities, and culture. In turn, they reshape those same social worlds through their actions, stories, and legacies. Heroism is therefore not simply something extraordinary people do. It is one of the primary ways humanity learns, grows, and becomes its better self.

Allison, S. T., & Goethals, G. R. (2027). Heroes: What they do and why we need them (2nd ed.).  Oxford University Press.

  • Mature Heroism (2027)

Mature heroism is a deep understanding of heroic action that embraces its full developmental, emotional, moral, and social complexity without diminishing our admiration for it. It recognizes that the deepest acts of courage often arise when there are no perfect choices, only the responsibility to pursue the wisest and most compassionate course available. Whereas popular heroism says “Heroes are amazing,” mature heroism says “Heroism is extraordinarily complex.”

Allison, S. T., & Goethals, G. R. (2027). Heroes: What they do and why we need them (2nd ed.).  Oxford University Press.

  • Everyday Antiheroism (2027)

Everyday antiheroism refers to the morally complex ways ordinary people strive to do good while continuing to struggle with unresolved pain, inner conflict, or psychological wounds. Rather than representing the opposite of heroism, everyday antiheroism reflects an incomplete or imperfect heroic journey in which courage, virtue, and growth coexist with lingering suffering, moral ambiguity, or personal limitation.

Prusa, I. & Allison, S. T. (2027). Everyday antiheroism: The pain with a thousand faces. In J. Pascoe et al. (Eds.), Everyday Heroism: Courage, compassion and the power to change the world. Cambridge Scholars.

  • Recursive Process of Situationally Activated Everyday Heroism (2027)

Everyday heroism is situationally activated when external circumstances cause ordinary people to act with courage, compassion, or moral responsibility. In a recursive process, the situation provides the opportunity for heroism, and the heroic actor then becomes part of the situational context that influences the next generation of everyday heroes.

Allison, S. T. (2027). Philip Zimbardo and Carl Sagan: Situationally activated everyday heroism in public life. In C. Maslach et al. (Eds.), Elgar Companion to Philip G. Zimbardo. Elgar.

  • Heroism as Emotional Integration (2026)

Heroism rarely emerges from a single emotion acting alone. More often, it arises from the successful integration of competing emotional forces. To take heroic action, people must integrate positive emotions (e.g., empathy, hope, compassion) with negative emotions  (e.g., fear, anger, uncertainty).

Allison, S. T. (2026). Heroism as emotional integration: A process model of emotion-driven heroic action. Heroism Science, 11, 87-116.

  • The Glass Mask Phenomenon (2026)

The Glass Mask describes a subtle imbalance in how leadership is perceived: the same movements that help men be seen as both capable leaders and admirable figures do not always carry the same meaning when expressed by women. By weakening the natural link between authority and admiration, the Glass Mask makes women’s leadership less immediately recognizable as heroic and more likely to be viewed through caution or constraint.

Allison, S. T., & Goethals, G. R. (2026). Motional Intelligence: The Power of Movement in Leadership. Emerald.

  • Chrono-Archetypes (2025)

Chrono-archetypes are symbolic inner personas grounded in Zimbardo’s Time Perspective Theory. They are dynamic, narrative-based identities (e.g., Legacy Keeper, Visionary, Wounded Historian) that respond to everyday “calls to action,” including ethical dilemmas, crises, and opportunities for prosocial innovation.

Allison, S. T. (2025). Temporal identities and moral courage: A chrono-archetype model of workplace heroism. Journal of Organizational Psychology, 25(3), 129-145.

  • Amalgamated Heroes (2024)

An amalgamated hero is a legendary, cultural hero who is derived from a complex blending of similar historical figures and our own cognitive embellishments of those figures.

Allison, S. T. & Hutchins, R. (2024). Amalgamated heroes. In S. T. Allison, J. K. Beggan, and G. R. Goethals (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Heroism Studies. Springer.

  • Heroism-by-Proxy (2024)

Heroism-by-proxy describes a psychological phenomenon that occurs when an individual develops a strong psychological association with a hero or a heroic figure, leading to a sense of personal heroism. Heroism-by-proxy can be constructive when it inspires heroism but can be destructive when it engenders either complacency or a psychological identification with violent, divisive leaders.

Allison, S. T., Beggan, J. K., & Goethals, G. R. (2024). Heroism-by-Proxy. In S. T. Allison, J. K. Beggan, and G. R. Goethals (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Heroism Studies. Springer.

  • Perfect Confluence and Herois (2024)

The “perfect storm” is a term often used metaphorically to describe situations where a convergence of multiple factors leads to a particularly significant or catastrophic outcome. The perfect confluence refers to any convergence of circumstances that results in a particularly positive or heroic outcome.

Allison, S. T. (2024). Perfect storm, perfect confluence, and heroism. In S. T. Allison, J. K. Beggan, and G. R. Goethals (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Heroism Studies. Springer.

  • Intuitive Heroism (2024)

Intuitive heroism refers to how individuals naturally and intuitively make sense of heroism. People have their own ideas about what heroes do, what heroes are like, and what motivates heroism. These intuitive notions of heroism are accurate in some ways but also contain factual errors and misunderstandings about heroism.

Allison, S. T. (2024). Intuitive heroism. In S. T. Allison, J. K. Beggan, and G. R. Goethals (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Heroism Studies. Springer.

  • Heroism Attribution Error (2024)

The tendency of people to confuse fame for heroism, such that they attribute heroism to celebrities who are famous for non-heroic reasons.

Allison, S. T. (2024). Heroism attribution error. In S. T. Allison, J. K. Beggan, and G. R. Goethals (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Heroism Studies. Springer.

  • Hero Illiteracy (2024)

The lack of knowledge about heroism, or a misunderstanding about what comprises heroism. The condition can afflict an individual or an entire society. It can include an inability to distinguish heroes from villains and an erroneous belief that money, fame, and celebrity status are the determinants of heroism.

.Allison, S. T., & Beggan, J. K.  (2024). Hero Illiteracy. In S. T. Allison, J. K. Beggan, and G. R. Goethals (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Heroism Studies. Springer.

  • Motional Intelligence (2023, 2026)

A form of kinesthetic intelligence that enables leaders to move the emotions of their followers. It is the ability of heroic (and villainous) leaders to use their body movements and voices effectively in a way that inspires and mobilizes followers.

Allison, S. T. (2023). Motional intelligence and leadership. In G. R. Goethals, S. T. Allison, & G. J. Sorenson (Eds.). The SAGE Encyclopedia of Leadership Studies. Sage.

Allison, S. T., & Goethals, G. R. (2026). Motional intelligence: The power of movement in leadership. Emerald.

  • Dynamic Negotiated Exchange Theory of Heroism (2022)

The dynamic negotiated exchange model of heroism refers to the processes by which the implicit exchange agreement between heroes and their followers evolves over time. Terms of the exchange agreement often change in response to a major crisis, such as the COVID pandemic of early 2020s.

Allison, S. T., & Beggan, J. K. (2022). The dynamic negotiated exchange model of heroism and heroic leadership: Lessons from the COVID-19 pandemic. Interdisciplinary Journal of Leadership Studies, 1, 15-31.

  • Heroic Balance (2021)

The ability of the hero to achieve a healthy psychological balance needed to achieve their heroic mission. Heroes must balance intuition with reason; emotion with logic; self-confidence with humility; autonomy with dependency; personal life with professional life; and more.

Allison, S. T. (2021). Beth Harmon’s hero’s journey: The psychology of heroism in The Queen’s Gambit. Palsgrove.

  • Heroic Autonomy (2021, 2024)

The imperative of the hero to perform the last and most crucial heroic act alone — independent from friends and mentors who have helped the hero prepare for that heroic moment.

Allison, S. T. (2021). Beth Harmon’s hero’s journey: The psychology of heroism in The Queen’s Gambit. Palsgrove.

Allison, S. T. (2024). Heroic autonomy. In S. T. Allison, J. K. Beggan, and G. R. Goethals (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Heroism Studies. Springer.

  • Puer Aeternus as an Obstacle to Heroism (2020)

The Puer Aeternus complex describes an adult, often a man, who remains in an extended state of adolescence, exhibiting traits commonly associated with youth. The phenomenon represents a significant barrier to personal growth and heroism due to its characteristic evasion of the hero’s journey that transforms people into their best, most heroic selves.

Allison, S. T., Goethals, G. R., & Spyrou, S. P. (2020). Donald Trump as the archetypal puer aeternus: The psychology of mature and immature leadership. In K. Bezio & G. R. Goethals (Eds.), Leadership, populism, and resistance. Edward Elgar.

  • The Hero Androgyny Phenomenon (2020)

The tendency of heroes to possess a healthy blend of both masculine and feminine traits. The blend combines a sense of agency, autonomy, and effectiveness with  moral warmth, empathy, and communality.

Hoyt, C. L., Allison, S. T., Barnowski, A., & Sultan, A. (2020). Lay theories of heroism and leadership: The role of gender, communion, and agency. Social Psychology, 51, 381-395.

  • Heroic Wholeness Imperative (2020)

The mandate of leaders to promote psychological wholeness and well-being by meeting the higher-level transcendent needs of followers.

Allison, S. T. & Goethals, G. R. (2020). The heroic leadership imperative: How leaders inspire and mobilize change. Emerald.

  • Heroic Leadership Imperative (2020)

The mandate of transforming heroic leaders to meet the individual, collective, and transcendent needs of their followers.

Allison, S. T. & Goethals, G. R. (2020). The heroic leadership imperative: How leaders inspire and mobilize change. Emerald.

  • Romance of Heroism (2019)

The romance of heroism refers to people’s idealistic and quixotic notions of heroes, which leads to exaggerated perceptions of the heroic qualities in certain types of people, especially under conditions of uncertainty. Romanticized desires to designate people as heroes are subject to distortion and can induce people to choose false heroes.

Goethals, G. R., & Allison, S. T. (2019). The romance of heroism and heroic leadership: Ambiguity, attribution, and apotheosis. Emerald.

  • Seven Barriers to Heroic Transformation (2019)

Seven ways people avoid heroic transformation: self-ignorance, impoverished environments, personal trauma, victim identification, absence of mentors, mental/physical illness, and lack of psychological flexibility.

Allison, S. T., Goethals, G. R., Marrinan, A. R., Parker, O. M., Spyrou, S. P., Stein, M. (2019). The metamorphosis of the hero: Principles, processes, and purpose. Frontiers in Psychology, 10, 606.

  • Heroic Consciousnes (2019, 2024)

Heroic consciousness is a state of heightened awareness, reasoning, emotional experience, self-identity, intention, and will, all aimed at saving lives, pursuing a noble cause, and promoting the greater good.

Allison, S. T. (2019). Heroic consciousness. Heroism Science, 4, 1-43.

Allison, S. T. (2024). Heroic consciousness. In S. T. Allison, J. K. Beggan, and G. R. Goethals (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Heroism Studies. Springer.

  • Heroic Lag (2019, 2024)

Activist heroes are often ahead of their time, advocating changes that challenge prevailing assumptions, power structures, or group identities. Heroic lag refers to the delay between the time when a hero champions a transformative idea and the time when society comes to recognize the value of that idea.

Goethals, G. R., & Allison, S. T. (2019). The romance of heroism and heroic leadership: Ambiguity, attribution, and apotheosis. Emerald.

Allison, S. T. (2024). Heroic lag. In S. T. Allison, J. K. Beggan, and G. R. Goethals (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Heroism Studies. Springer.

  • Transcendent and Trapped Immortality (2018, 2024)

The tendency of people to perceive dead heroes and villains differently. Specifically, we believe deceased good-doers achieve transcendent immortality, with their souls persisting beyond space and time. In contrast, evil-doers are perceived to have trapped immortality, with their souls persisting on Earth, bound to a physical location.

Gray, K., Anderson, S., Doyle, C. M., Hester, N., Schmitt, P., Vonasch, A., Allison, S. T., and Jackson, J. C. (2018). To be immortal, do good or evil. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 44, 868-880.

Allison, S. T. (2024). Transcendent immortality and heroism. In S. T. Allison, J. K. Beggan, and G. R. Goethals (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Heroism Studies. Springer.

  • The Personal Heroic Imperative (2018)

Each human being’s built-in mandate to fulfill their heroic imperative by imagining and creating their own heroic growth.

Efthimiou, O., Allison, S. T., & Franco, Z. E. (2018). Heroism and wellbeing in the 21st century: Recognizing our personal heroic imperative. In O. Efthimiou, S. T. Allison, & Z. E. Franco (Eds.), Heroism and wellbeing in the 21st Century: Applied and emerging perspectives.  Routledge.

  • Three Heroic Transformative Arcs (2017)

The developmental process  of ordinary people transforming into heroes by transforming from a state of egocentricity to sociocentricity; from dependence to autonomy; and from stagnation to growth.

Allison, S. T., & Goethals, G. R. (2017). The hero’s transformation. In S. T. Allison, G. R. Goethals, & R. M. Kramer (Eds.), Handbook of heroism and heroic leadership. Routledge.

  • Six Types of Heroic Transformation (2017, 2024)

Six commons patterns of transformation in heroes that involve changes in their mental, emotional, physical, spiritual, moral, and motivational state.

Allison, S. T., Goethals, G. R., & Kramer, R. M. (2017). Setting the scene: The rise and coalescence of heroism science. In S. T. Allison, G. R. Goethals, & R. M. Kramer (Eds.), Handbook of heroism and heroic leadership. Routledge.

Allison, S. T. (2024). Heroic transformation. In S. T. Allison, J. K. Beggan, and G. R. Goethals (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Heroism Studies. Springer.

  • Six Benefits of Suffering (2016, 2024)

The identification of benefits of heroic suffering as offering (1) redemption, (2) developmental progress, (3) humility, (4) compassion, (5) social union, and (6) meaning and purpose.

Allison, S. T., & Setterberg, G. C. (2016). Suffering and sacrifice: Individual and collective benefits, and implications for leadership. In S. T. Allison, C. T. Kocher, & G. R. Goethals (Eds), Frontiers in spiritual leadership: Discovering the better angels of our nature. Palgrave Macmillan.

Allison, S. T. (2024). Suffering of the hero. In S. T. Allison, J. K. Beggan, and G. R. Goethals (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Heroism Studies. Springer.

  • Need-Based Heroism — AKA The Johnny Carson Effect (2016, 2024)

The tendency of people’s current need states to determine their choice of heroes, with these need-states changing as a function of people’s developmental stages and their changing life circumstances. (named after Johnny Carson’s quip that after all his divorces, his hero changed from Babe Ruth to King Henry VIII)

Allison, S. T., & Goethals, G. R. (2016). Hero worship: The elevation of the human spirit. Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour, 46, 187-210.

Allison, S. T. (2024). Need-based heroism. In S. T. Allison, J. K. Beggan, and G. R. Goethals (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Heroism Studies. Springer.

  • Epistemic and Energizing Functions of Heroism (2014)

The conceptualization of the functions of heroism that includes epistemic needs involving the imparting of wisdom and emerging needs involving healing, growing, and inspiration.

Allison, S. T., & Goethals, G. R. (2014). “Now he belongs to the ages”: The heroic leadership dynamic and deep narratives of greatness. In Goethals, G. R., et al. (Eds.), Conceptions of leadership: Enduring ideas and emerging insights. Palgrave Macmillan.

  • The Heroic Leadership Dynamic (2014)

A system of psychological forces that can explain the complex relationship between heroes and their followers. It explains how we are drawn to heroes, how we benefit from these heroes, and how our choice of heroes changes over time.

Allison, S. T., & Goethals, G. R. (2014). “Now he belongs to the ages”: The heroic leadership dynamic and deep narratives of greatness. In Goethals, G. R., et al. (Eds.), Conceptions of leadership: Enduring ideas and emerging insights. Palgrave Macmillan.

  • Social Influence Based Taxonomy of Heroism (2012)

The scientific identification of heroes as Transforming, Transfigured, Traditional, Transparent, Transposed, Tragic, Transitional, Transitory, Trending, and Transcendent.

Allison, S. T., & Goethals, G. R. (2013). Heroic leadership: An influence taxonomy of 100 exceptional individuals. Routledge.

  • The Great Eight Traits of Heroes (2011)

The discovery that people believe that heroes possess the traits of wise, strong, charismatic, caring, resilient, reliable, selfless, and inspiring.

Allison, S. T., & Goethals, G. R. (2011). Heroes: What they do and why we need them.  Oxford University Press.

  • The Underdog Abandonment Effect (2008)

The tendency of people to no longer root for underdog heroes when their success has low self-relevance and low consequences.

Kim, J., Allison, S. T., Eylon, D., Goethals, G., Markus, M., McGuire, H., & Hindle, S. (2008). Rooting for (and then Abandoning) the Underdog. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 38, 2550-2573.

  • The Frozen in Time Effect (2005)

People’s tendency to resist changing their impressions of dead heroes compared to living heroes.

Eylon, D., & Allison, S. T. (2005). The frozen in time effect in evaluations of the dead. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 31, 1708-1717.

Allison, S. T. (2024). Frozen in time effect and heroism. In S. T. Allison, J. K. Beggan, and G. R. Goethals (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Heroism Studies. Springer.

  • The Death Positivity Bias (2005)

The tendency of people to evaluate the dead more favorably than the living. This is one way we “heroize” past legendary figures.

Allison, S. T., & Eylon, D. (2005). The demise of leadership: Death positivity biases in posthumous impressions of leaders. In D. Messick & R. Kramer (Eds.), The Psychology of Leadership: New Perspectives and Research (pp 295-317). New York: Erlbaum.

Allison, S. T. (2024). Death positivity bias and heroism. In S. T. Allison, J. K. Beggan, and G. R. Goethals (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Heroism Studies. Springer.

       LOOKING AHEAD

Heroism science continues to evolve. Many of the contributions listed above have generated new questions, theoretical models, and lines of investigation that are still unfolding. As our understanding of heroism grows, this page will continue to document new discoveries that illuminate how heroes emerge, inspire, develop, and shape the world around them.

The Hidden Heroism of Human Movement

By Scott T. Allison

When we think about intelligence, we usually think about the mind. Intelligence is commonly associated with reasoning, memory, language, creativity, or emotional awareness. Yet one of the oldest and most powerful forms of human intelligence may reside not in words or abstract thought, but in movement itself.

Long before human beings developed spoken language, our ancestors communicated through posture, gesture, rhythm, pacing, and spatial orientation. A sudden movement could warn of danger. A calm posture could reassure others. A coordinated group movement could signal trust, unity, and shared purpose. Human beings moved meaningfully before they spoke meaningfully.

My colleague George Goethals and I use the term Motional Intelligence (MI) to describe this overlooked dimension of social life. MI refers to the ability to use body movement intentionally to influence others, to accurately interpret the movements of other people, and to regulate one’s own bodily behavior in response to changing social situations. In short, MI is the intelligence of movement in human interaction.

This idea differs from emotional intelligence, which focuses primarily on recognizing and managing emotions. MI centers on the moving body itself—on posture, gesture, timing, rhythm, stillness, synchrony, and physical presence. It asks how movement shapes perception, connection, influence, and social meaning.

Once you begin paying attention to MI, you see it everywhere.

Think about how quickly we form impressions of people. Before anyone says a word, we often sense whether someone appears confident, anxious, trustworthy, dominant, warm, awkward, or emotionally withdrawn. We infer these qualities from movement: how a person enters a room, occupies space, approaches others, or carries themselves physically. Human beings constantly read one another through motion, often unconsciously.

Heroism itself may depend heavily on MI. Before people are recognized as heroes, they are often first perceived as calm under pressure, physically decisive, emotionally grounded, or capable of stepping forward when others hesitate. Movement frequently serves as the first visible signal of courage and agency.

Film offers striking examples. Some of cinema’s most memorable characters communicate more through movement than dialogue. Charlie Chaplin’s Tramp expresses vulnerability and compassion almost entirely through physical timing and gesture. Humphrey Bogart’s Rick Blaine in Casablanca projects emotional restraint through stillness and minimal movement. Heath Ledger’s Joker in The Dark Knight unsettles viewers through erratic pacing, invasive proximity, and unpredictable bodily rhythms. Their movements communicate psychological depth before words ever do.

Politics and leadership reveal similar dynamics. During the 2016 U.S. presidential debates, one of the most memorable moments involved not policy but movement. Donald Trump paced closely behind Hillary Clinton while she spoke, and viewers interpreted the same physical behavior in dramatically different ways—some seeing dominance and confidence, others perceiving intimidation and intrusion. The moment illustrated how bodily motion can shape emotional climates and public interpretation as powerfully as spoken language.

But MI is not limited to leaders, actors, or charismatic personalities. It permeates everyday life. Long-married couples often move in subtle synchrony, anticipating each other’s actions almost unconsciously. Friends walking together gradually align their pace. Parents instinctively soothe distressed children through rhythmic rocking and calming physical presence. Human relationships are constantly choreographed through movement.

Importantly, MI is probably not a fixed talent reserved for a gifted few. Like many forms of intelligence, it can likely be strengthened through awareness and practice. People can learn to become more attentive to bodily signals, more skillful in regulating tension through posture and pacing, and more accurate in interpreting the movements of others.

In an increasingly digital world, this may matter more than ever. Texting, email, and online communication strip away much of the movement information our brains evolved to process. Yet even advanced technologies—from virtual reality to social robotics—are discovering that believable movement remains essential to creating trust, connection, and emotional realism.

Perhaps this is the deeper lesson of motional intelligence: human beings do not merely think and speak their way through social life. We move our way through it. And learning to move with greater awareness, empathy, and responsibility may become one of the most important human capacities of the future.

References

Allison, S. T., & Goethals, G. R. (2026). Motional intelligence: The power of movement in leadership. Emerald.

= = = = = = = = = = = =

The Missing Story: Why We Still Need a Shared Hero Narrative

By Scott T. Allison

If you step back and look at modern life, something feels off. We are more connected than ever, yet less unified. Stories surround us—streaming endlessly across screens—yet the kinds of shared narratives that once brought people together seem harder to find .

So what changed?

To be sure, no society has ever been perfectly unified. People have always disagreed, and cultures have always contained competing ideas. But many earlier societies did share broad narrative frameworks—religious, moral, and mythological—that helped people make sense of life.

These stories provided a kind of common language, helping answer enduring questions: Who are we? What matters? How should we live?

Over time, scholars have argued that this shared narrative ground has weakened. The sociologist Émile Durkheim warned that modern societies risk falling into anomie when shared values erode. Max Weber described an “age of disenchantment,” where scientific rationality strips the world of mystery and meaning. More recently, thinkers like Charles Taylor have suggested that while people still search for purpose, they often do so alone, without a shared framework to guide them.

But the problem is not that we lack stories. In fact, we are surrounded by them—superheroes, political identities, cultural narratives, and personal stories shaped online. The real issue is fragmentation. We have many stories, but fewer that we hold in common.

That distinction matters.

In earlier cultures, shared myths often acted as social glue. They offered not just entertainment, but a sense of belonging and direction—a narrative map of human experience. Today, that map is harder to locate.

This is where Joseph Campbell’s work becomes especially relevant. After studying myths across cultures, Campbell identified a recurring pattern he called the Hero’s Journey. In this story, an ordinary person is called to adventure, faces challenges, grows through struggle, and returns to serve others.

Campbell believed this pattern resonates because it reflects something fundamental about being human: we all face obstacles, we all change, and we all have the potential to contribute.

Of course, not every culture fits neatly into this framework. Some traditions emphasize community over individual heroes, or cyclical rather than linear stories. But even with these differences, the Hero’s Journey captures a widely recognizable pattern—one that continues to show up across time and place.

So what role might it play today?

While we may no longer share a single mythology, we can still share a common structure of meaning. The Hero’s Journey doesn’t tell us what to believe. Instead, it offers a flexible framework for understanding how growth unfolds—through challenge, courage, and transformation.

In that sense, it can serve as a kind of shared narrative grammar in a diverse world. Without something like this, it becomes harder to talk about purpose, growth, and responsibility. We risk living in separate narrative worlds, each with its own logic and values.

The Hero’s Journey offers a bridge.

It reminds us that struggle is part of life, that growth requires stepping into uncertainty, and that our journeys are not just about ourselves. At its best, it is not a story of personal triumph alone, but of return—of using what we’ve gained to help others.

This is where the idea becomes practical.

We can introduce the Hero’s Journey at home, helping children see challenges as opportunities for growth. Schools can use it to support resilience and identity development. Faith communities can connect it to traditions of transformation and service. Even organizations can use it to frame leadership and purpose.

This is not about imposing a single worldview. It is about offering a shared lens—one that is flexible enough to include many perspectives, yet structured enough to create common ground.

Because beneath our differences, we all face moments that call us forward—moments that ask us to grow, to act, and to contribute.

Perhaps myths have not disappeared. Perhaps we have simply lost sight of the patterns that still connect us.

The Hero’s Journey reminds us that even in a fragmented world, there remains a shared rhythm to human life: challenge, transformation, and return. It is not the only story we need—but it may be one of the few that can still bring us together.

And in a divided world, that may matter more than ever.

References

Allison, S. T. (2024). Hero Monomyth. In S. T. Allison, J. K. Beggan, and G. R. Goethals (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Heroism Studies. Springer.

= = = = = = = = =